Don’t whine, don’t watch Jolly LLB if it offends you, SC tells lawyers #FOE #Censorship


Utkarsh Anand : New Delhi, Sat Mar 16 2013,

Defeated once in court but still determined to protect the “dignity” of their profession, a group of lawyers from Meerut knocked on the doors of the Supreme Court on Friday to stop the release of Jolly LLB. Only to be told by the court that Jolly was only a film that need not be taken to heart.

Trailers of the film — which released on Friday — show Jagdish Tyagi aka Jolly LLB (Arshad Warsi), a struggling lawyer from Meerut, get a rap from a judge (Saurabh Shukla) for misspelling prosecution as prostitution. Lawyers from the UP town found it offensive and contemptuous.

The Supreme Court, however, showed it was not willing to lose its sense of humour.

“What is your problem with the dialogues? In our courts also, we get several petitions with spelling and other mistakes. Appeals are spelt as apples, section 171 as section 17, and similar such mistakes. These things do happen in courts,” a bench of Justices R M Lodha and Madan B Lokur said.

The lawyers, who claimed they were graduates of Meerut Law College, Chaudhary Charan Singh University, had approached the apex court against Delhi High Court‘s refusal to stay the release of the film, which they said was defamatory to the legal fraternity.

The SC regretted the lawyers’ “unnecessary” grumbling after their counsel conceded that Jagdish Tyagi aka Jolly LLB was not a real person. “Then what are you complaining about? It is only a fictitious character, based on a fictitious story. This is shocking,” the bench said.

Justice Lodha, who spent 13 years as a judge of Bombay High Court, said: “These things happen in movies. They show Bombay High Court’s door and gate and then show something else happening inside. These are all fictitious things.”

When the petitioners’ counsel attempted to draw the court’s attention to allegedly defamatory dialogues in the film, Justice Lodha recalled Shakespeare — ‘The first thing we do, let’s kill all the lawyers’ in Measure for Measure.

“We are not using those words here, but you don’t have to bother about everything,” he said. It is for the Censor Board to consider the language of a film, and not our job,” Justice Lodha said.

The court advised the lawyers not to watch the film or take their families to the theatre if they found the dialogues offensive. “If the movie is useless in your opinion, don’t watch it at all. You know you will not enjoy it, so don’t go. You are giving undue importance to the issue. Let those go to theatres who want to watch it.”

With the writing on the wall, the lawyers sought permission to withdraw their plea, and the court ordered: “Dismissed as withdrawn”.

 

#India – Uttar Pradesh engineer is first to be booked under new stalking law #Vaw #Justice


20-year-old would harass Bhayandar woman, who used to be his neighbour, with lewd late-night calls

 

Ram Parmar, Mumbai Mirror March 16,2013

 

 

A 20-year-old engineering student from Uttar Pradesh has been arrested by the Navghar (Bhayander East) police for stalking a married woman who used to live next door to him in Varanasi. Vishal Verma is the first suspect to be charged under the new Section 354-D (stalking) of the Indian Penal Code, which is now a non-bailable offence.

Verma, a first-year engineering student at IIMT Engineering College, Meerut, and a resident of Varanasi, first met the woman when she was unmarried. He became infatuated with her and his obsession continued even after she got married and moved from Varanasi to Bhayandar. Inspector Dinkar Pingle of Navghar police station said Verma would telephone her late at night and harass her, asking her for “kisses” over the phone.

On February 21, Verma again called the woman to profess his love for her and said he would come down to Bhayander to meet her. He asked her for a kiss, at which the woman slammed the phone down. Verma continued to telephone her, but she ignored his calls. “Finally, the woman registered a complaint with us on March 3 and we started to investigate the matter,” said Inspector Pingle. “We sent a team to Benares, which arrested Verma and charged him under the new Section 354 (D) of the IPC,” added Pingle. Since it is a now a non-bailable offence, Verma has been remanded in police custody till Monday, when he will be produced before the Thane Sessions Court.

 

 

Man killed after exposing khaps on TV, wife fears she will be killed #SatyamevJayate #AamirKhan #Honorkilling


S Raju, Hindustan Times and Dainik Bhaskar, CNNIBN
Meerut, November 26, 2012

Casual labourer Abdul Hakim, 29, who exposed the ugly face of khap panchayats against lovers in Aamir Khan’s TV show Satyamev Jayate earlier this year was eliminated in full public glare in his remote native village Adoli in western UP’s Bulandshahar districton Thursday. HT learnt on  Sunday that five armed men shot Hakim dead in full public view when he was on his way to the village doctor’s clinic to get medicines for his pregnant wife, Mehawish, 25.

 Speaking to CNN-IBN, she also said that she feared for her life. “They have killed my husband, they will kill me now. I am 9 months pregnant. My husband would have been alive if police protection was provided,” the woman, Mehwish, said.

Aamir Khan, the host of popular television series Satyamev Jayate that was aired every Sunday at 11am on Star Plus, was shocked to hear the news about the killing of Abdul Hakim, a participant in the talk show.

On June 3, 2012 Aamir tried to question the means of the Khap panchayat and the ways in which they try to discourage love marriages in the same gotra. Honour killing was one of the salient features of this discussion. And it was the example of Abdul Hakim and his wife Mehawish who had eloped from Merut to get married in November 2010 that was brought forward.

On November 22, almost five months after that episode was aired, the 28-year-old Hakim was shot dead in Bulandshahr. On hearing this, Aamir said, “Will speak to the government authorities in UP (Uttar Pradesh) to help and ensure the family is safe. The culprits must be brought to the book. The case is registered on the basis of right facts.”

Abdul’s wife said, “They have killed my husband, they will kill me now. I am nine months pregnant. My husband would have been alive if police protection was provided.”

According to Abdul’s brother, the assailants shot Hakim in full view of the public. But the police officials are of the opinion that he was killed as a result of some personal feud.

We hope the family gets speedy justice.

“They ambushed him outside the clinic and pumped several bullets into him,” said the victim’s elder brother Yusuf Hakim.

Abdul and Mehawish eloped in November 2010 and got married in Meerut before moving to Delhi. A panchayat decreed death for the couple and terrorised Abdul’s family as a result of which young family members left the village, sources said.

Actor Aamir Khan expressed grief over the killing of Abdul Hakim, the casual labourer who exposed the Khap panchayat on the TV show ‘Satyamev Jayate’.
On June 3, 2012 Aamir tried to question the means of the Khap panchayat and the ways in which they try to discourage love marriages in the same gotra. Honour killing was one of the salient features of this discussion. And it was the example of Abdul Hakim and his wife Mehawish who had eloped from Meerut to get married in November 2010 that was brought forward.

On November 22, almost five months after that episode was aired, the 28-year-old Hakim was shot dead in Bulandshahr. On hearing this, Aamir said, “Will speak to the government authorities in UP (Uttar Pradesh) to help and ensure the family is safe. The culprits must be brought to the book. The case is registered on the basis of right facts.”

Abdul’s wife said, “They have killed my husband, they will kill me now. I am nine months pregnant. My husband would have been alive if police protection was provided.”

According to Abdul’s brother, the assailants shot Hakim in full view of the public. But the police officials are of the opinion that he was killed as a result of some personal feud.

We hope the family gets speedy justice.

Terming the incident as unfortunate, Aamir Khan said, “Will speak to the government authorities in UP to help and ensure the family is safe. The culprits must be brought to the book. The case is registered on the basis of right facts.”
Hakim was killed in cold blood in full public view on Thursday.
According to media reports, five armed men shot Hakim when he was going to the village doctor’s clinic to get medicines for his pregnant wife, Mehawish.
Talking to the media, Hakim’s brother said the assailants pumped several bullets into him.
However, the police claimed that it was not a case of honour killing as none of the accused named in the FIR by the deceased’s brother was from Mahvish side.
Related articles