Dr Rina Mukherji wins case of sexual harassment against ‘The Statesman’ after 10 years #Vaw #Justice


The Cost of Justice

February 13, 2013 News, feministindia.com
Rina Mukherji-1In 2002, Dr Rina Mukherji, then a senior reporter working for The Statesman complained of sexual harassment against Ishan Joshi, the news coordinator for the paper. On October 12, 2002, she was fired from her job.

Dr. Mukherji, then approached Network of Women in Media in India (NWMI) , the West Bengal Commission for Women and the Labour Commissioner. The Statesman refused conciliation proceedings and the labour suit moved to the Industrial Tribunal against the management of The Statesman . Ten years later, on February 6, 2013, the Court ruled in her favour. Rina Mukherji recounts her struggle for justice in this first person account

A full decade. That is the amount of time I have taken to win justice. More than three years of the period was lost due to vacant courts bereft of judges or stalling of proceedings on various pretexts by lawyers from the opposing side.

I was lucky to have been supported by many in the profession, as also outside it. Professor Jashodhara Bagchi, the then Chairperson of the West Bengal Commission for Women, went through a harrowing time trying to settle the dispute with The Statesman. Her experience, though, exposed the flaws in the system and led us to realize that the Commission lacked “teeth.” We also realized that an employer could easily upstage a complainant by dragging a dispute to court, and with the judicial system we have, a matter would drag on for years. In the meanwhile, a complainant loses precious years of professional life, and is blacklisted by employers.

Even if you land up a full-time job with an employer who is extremely supportive of your plight, it is difficult to work when you have to keep shunting between courts for months (and years) together. In my case, I had a labour suit to attend in Kolkata, and two libel suits-one civil and the other criminal with the latter in Delhi, to attend to. I was left with no option but to freelance, notwithstanding the regular drain on my resources.

One of the worst problems when you have a complaint of sexual harassment at the workplace-is that no lawyer is willing to take up the case. They are apprehensive of losing the case, since they lack experience in such matters. (This again, is because of the deafening silence on such issues in a patriarchal society, which manifests itself in women keeping away from reporting on them). In my case, it was a media house, and hence even scarier! If not for Ms. Sutapa Chakrabarty of the Human Rights Law Network, (HRLN), an NGO providing legal aid to those who suffer a breach of their human rights, I might have had to plead my case myself.

There is another point I wish to make about those who swear by the names of celebrated legal luminaries. The lawyers at HRLN who fought my case were young and bright; and most of all, committed. Shamit Sanyal, Debashis Banerjee and his wife, Rajashri Banerjee, and Ambalika Roy brought a degree of commitment that is undeniable.

In fact, Debashis Banerjee worked hard to put forth the winning arguments that ultimately decided the case in my favour and got me an award from the Industrial tribunal granting my reinstatement and full back wages from the time of my termination by the management of The Statesman. And this was –to quote him- the “first case he had taken up as an advocate.”

The police, even if they be sympathetic and helpful, are utterly confused about how to deal with a white-collar offender. Eve-teasing or molestation by roadside miscreants is easy for them to deal with. But an educated man who is highly-placed in an organization can refuse to co-operate with the police investigation and easily get away with it due to loopholes in the legal system.

The Vishakha Guidelines were formulated with the best of intentions. But sexual harassment complaints committees in organizations are, more often than not, a total farce since the Guidelines presuppose organizations to be fair in bringing offenders to justice when a complaint is made to them. In my case, there was no such committee at The Statesman during my tenure. The pressure put in by Network of Women in Media in India ( NWMI), had my ex-employers hurriedly set up their committee.

My complaint, however, was never investigated into. Even as they refused to take cognizance of my complaint, The Statesman actually promoted the offender to a higher position.

One only hopes women will have a better deal once the Sexual Harassment at Workplace Bill becomes an Act in the near future.

The industrial tribunal has awarded me reinstatement and full back wages from the time I was terminated in October 2002 on the ground that it was illegal. However, the libel suits-filed against me by The Statesman and Ishan Joshi for having tarnished their reputation are yet to be decided. I still have a long way to go for a full victory.

Rina Mukherji is a senior journalist currently based in Kolkata. She has worked for over two decades in the print and online media specializing in issues related to sustainable development, the environment and human rights . She is the recipient of the 2011-2012 Laadli Media Award for Gender Sensitivity ( Eastern Region) and several international fellowships for reporting on science, the environment and public health

33 comments on “Dr Rina Mukherji wins case of sexual harassment against ‘The Statesman’ after 10 years #Vaw #Justice

    • Realy, Madam you are true roll model for all in society who keeps quit after seeing lot of irregularities around them.People can inspire from your act.You have shown an example of courage .I can observe clearly in the country slowly slowly people are gathering together against corruption and sexual harassment of the Women in working place.Your act will definitely boost the flame.You are a true Hero of real life not reel (Film) life. I salute you.Thanks to crime petrol to bring your story forward to public in a fantastic way that bring tears in the eye of audience.

  1. Pingback: #Gujarat- Even police don’t have sexual complaint panel’ #womenrights #Vaw « kracktivist

  2. Pingback: Download Judgement- Rina Mukherjee vs The Statesman #sexualharassment #Vaw | kracktivist

  3. Pingback: IMMEDIATE RELEASE- Eclipsing Women’s Rights: Sexual Harassment at Sun TV # Vaw | kracktivist

  4. Pingback: Sun news reader suspended after sexual harassment plaint #Vaw #WTFnews | kracktivist

  5. Pingback: Sun TV Sexual Harassment Case- Response from Women Journalists #Vaw | kracktivist

  6. It really speaks a lot about our social justice and crimanl justice system in place to date. One is left to wonder the fate of many persons who might not have the will, resolve, support, education to fight against such incidents, especially when the outcome can take such a long time, almost a decade in this case. If an acclaimed journalist is made to face such an horrible situation, how will the ordinary people be able to win?
    I really salute Dr Rina for standing up and fighting for her moral rights.

  7. Great display of courage to fight for so long…I watched in crime patrol…and wish you success in the other two libel suits…filed by Ishan Joshi and Stateman. They cannot go away easily and I think now you should file a case against statesman management and Ishan Joshi and ask for compensation due to mental trauma which you and your family faced.

  8. First of all thanks to Crime Patrol for showing Dr. Rina’s case… so impressive & with each and every details .

    Dr. Rina we salute you , your family & other members who supported you for the truth and justice.
    You are very confident , courageous women & real role model.

  9. We are proud of you Dr. Mukherji for your struggle, committement, inspiration for your dignity. You have set an example for women force who don’t fight for justice & put up with harassment. Your patience & perseverance is is an encouragement for today’s woman. Salute you for showing us the path to fight against injustice, discrimination & also for having an attitude of “NEVER GIVE UP’. We are thankful to Crime Patrol for getting us introduce to role model like Dr. Mukherji.

  10. At the onset we are thankful to crime patrol to show us an exact replica of a case which makes us salute Dr Rina Mukherjee for her strength, her perseverence, to fight to the end.
    We are shocked and ashamed at the behaviour of businouss houses.
    We also suggest that Dr Mukherjee should now file a litigation for getting compensation for the physical and mental trauma that has been caused to her, and the loss of financial returns from her profession during this battle of 10 years.

  11. So extremely was I moved by Sony’s depiction of (I suppose) this case that I set out to search for it. I hope that Dr. Mukerji wins her case of libel and Joshi is brought to task. This speaks volumes about her guts and perseverence.

  12. Pingback: A woman who took on the high and mighty against sexual harassment! | Rachna Says

  13. My sister forced me to see the episode of crime petrol bcos it related to my case and that i could get some hints from it. there were tears in my eye, bcos you laid a path for me as my case is similar. half my struggle seems to be won. it took me 3 hrs yesterday just to get to know and be sure it was your case that they highlighted. Rina , hats off to you and thanks for boosting my self respect that i should not give up come what may. my case is 2 and half yrs old, but yet my foundation is not firm as the chairman of the NCW is not co-operative.Anyways thanks, i have already thanked the crime petrol team yesterday, This thanks comes to you from Mina (Names sounds rhyming) sure to win my case lets hope it reduces by some years as i will be stealing your judgement to attach to my case. God bless

  14. Yayyyyy!!!!! I am sooooo happy for her. I am also very happy that she is paid her wages. A very hearty congratulations to Rina and the whole team who fought with her….I wish many women take inspiration from this and not give up till they see victory.

  15. Congratulations Dr. Rina. We salute you for your patience. I am not very sure if it would be The Statesman or our judicial system responsible for the loooooooong delay in justice and hence causing all mental trauma and loss. Can’t somebody file a case against the court itself for delaying it deliberately. Would be interesting to see how a court reacts to such a truth but never accept it. A very sorry justice system – justice delayed is justice denied. Period !!!

  16. A big THANK YOU to all the people who have congratulated me here. I would like to add one little bit of information, Winning at the Tribunal is no guarantee that you are paid the compensation mentioned. Getting reinstated and getting your dues is another long haul. Our justice delivery system is so woefully inadequate that this must be pursued not just by me, but the state labour department too. So much for a victory!

    • Thanks to Crime Patrol which indeed documents in a more easier way than it really seems.
      One wonders when we all actually know the truth still we all act the other way except the person
      who suffers who always seems all alone …….still people like Rina make a difference in so many
      lives

    • Mam, pl. give ur mob. no. and mail ID. I am a journalist and fighting almost alone in a labor case. The opponent is a big political leader.

    • Congratulations Ma’am for winning the long long battle. But truth never gets suppressed. We are also working to fight workplace harassment. Our website is http://www.myhonor.in. We value your feedback and would really appreciate if you can share your experiences on our website. It will be a big boost to those who keep on suffering and remain mum. I have sent you a message through my FB account. Pls check and revert. Kind regards, Vipul

  17. I have been through something similar, but was young and had no support system of any sort. I know the pain and the strength of will it takes to move ahead. You are a lioness and an inspiration to many. God bless.

  18. I am a journalist and have been fighting for justice against illegal termination of 26 employees by the authority of NE Bangla satellite TV channel in Agartala. NE Bangla is owned by ex central minister Matang Sinh, so none has come out in my support. As the employees representative I am appearing in the Court. So I can understand how much pain she has experienced.
    Prasenjit Chakraborty
    Mob. 09436360912
    savenortheast@gmail.com

  19. Hello Mr. Prasenjit, You are really doing a great job! We are also working in same direction. Let’s join hands and fight together against the unjust. i have sent you an email also with my personal details. Pls revert on that. Thanks .Keep up the good work.

  20. Dear Doctor Rina Mukerji,

    Hats off to you for pulling this. You are a true inspiration and a hero for this fighting for justice. I just saw your case on youtube yesterday night (crime patrol).
    You are brave and very courageous, I wish my daughter becomes like you.

    Congratulations on this win in labor court. However, I am curious If there is any criminal proceeding against Ishan Joshi? Is he not put behind bars?

    BTW, All the best for the other 2 cases.

    Regards,
    Prakash
    The Netherlands

  21. Hi Madam, hats off to our courage….n congratulation…..n yes this would not be possible without the great support of your husband…….today saw ur story through crime petrol…….very touche….but u still manage to pay attention to your family…specially ur daughter……she must be proud of u……….am curious to know what exactly happy to Ishan Joshi…….?….once again congratulation …:)

    • Dear Doctor Rina Mukerji,-

      Has The Statesman appealed to higher court the decision of Tribunal Judgement. Are you being RE-Instead to your job and got the lump sump of the aerier since your termination. Please inform. (HASAN ABBAS ZAIDY)   SECURITY OFFICER BANARAS HINDU UNIVERSITY VARANASI   

Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in:

WordPress.com Logo

You are commenting using your WordPress.com account. Log Out / Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out / Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out / Change )

Google+ photo

You are commenting using your Google+ account. Log Out / Change )

Connecting to %s